Tutto il Giorno Southampton Gabby Karan does Southampton Italian redux

96 top rated
  • Tutto il Giorno Southampton

  • 56 Nugent St Southampton, NY 11968 USA (631) 377-3611
reviewed by
Ann Vine Editorial Review Author
  • The Scene:

    Located in the glossy white Nugent street space well known as Annie’s in recent years, Gabby Karan brings a Southampton sequel to her much-successful Sag Harbor eatery. While many will simply call her Donna Karan’s daughter, Gabby has a much-earned food reputation all her own with a signature dining room she penned personally. The new dining room is infused with innumerous French windowpanes and offers walkable location from downtown Southampton as well as the surrounding residential neighborhood. Expect a lot of claws and begging when trying for a prime weekend reservation, filling-up with many of the locals that made the drive to Sag Harbor in order to experience one of the hottest Hamptons eateries in previous years.

  • cuisine
  • price
    $$$$ ($45-$65)
  • payment options
    Visa, MasterCard, American Express
  • hours
    5pm-11pm, daily (June-Oct)
  • table to get
    Terrace
  • special features
    Hip Clientele, Celebrity Owner, Terrace
  • The Food:

    Standout Tutto il Giorno dishes include a breaded fritto misto of shrimp and calamari with a marinara, Branzino carpaccio or more traditional thinly sliced beef with garden-fresh basil and local olive oil. Under the helm of chefs like Scarpetta’s Scott Conant and Maurizio Marfoglia in recent years, expect the Southampton location to offer new dishes and chef headliners in the kitchen. Main course includes grilled seafood dishes as well as homemade pastas topped with locally made sausage and slow-cooked meats.

  • Last Word

    Gabby Karan brings Southampton redux of Tutto il Giorno to well-known Nugent Street space.

Related Reviews

  • 97

    18 Bay

    Farm-to-table eatery on Shelter Island

    Edible perfection found at former-general store on Shelter Island

    Editorial: Ann Vine

    read the review
  • 98

    Topping Rose House

    Tom Colicchio leads best Hamptons eatery to date

    Glamorous inn home to Top Chef eatery and lounge

    Editorial: Ann Vine

    read the review
  • 98

    Nammos Estiatorio

    Old Post House gets esteemed Greek eatery and lounge

    Sophisticated Greek dining room along Main Street

    Editorial: Ann Vine

    read the review